Thursday, March 8, 2012

Canada's Real Estate Market: A Sustainable Affordability Bubble?

Canadians have been seeing a lot of speculation about the future of the country's real estate market in recent months with "experts" falling on both sides of the fence; some saying that the market is fine, healthy and not due for any meaningful correction and others certain that the market is in for a big correction, especially because it is one of very few markets among developed nations that has not seen a price readjustment.  In this posting, I will present pricing data, measured by affordability, showing which Canadian markets are most affordable and which real estate markets are out of teh reach of prudent consumers.

Demographia recently released its 8th Annual International Housing Affordability Survey: 2012 in which they measure the affordability of housing in seven nations including Australia, New Zealand, Ireland, Hong Kong, Canada, the United Kingdom and the United States.  As I've noted on previous occasions, Demographia has a relatively unique way of measuring housing affordability by comparing the price of a median home to the gross (before tax) median annual household income in that market.  By dividing the median price by the median income in a given market, Demographia ends up with the median multiple for that market which gives a sense of affordability.  Historically, median multiples for the nations in the study  have ranged from 2.0 to 3.0 with 3.0 being the upper limit of affordability.  Demographia then takes the range of median multiples and breaks them down into one of four categories as shown on this chart:


In general, the Demographia Housing Affordability study has shown that housing in Canada is becoming less affordable, particularly in some markets with Vancouver being a standout example.  Of the six major real estate markets in Canada (population greater than 1 million people), three are considered moderately unaffordable and 3 are considered severely unaffordable as shown here in comparison to the other nations in the study:


Of all 325 markets in the study and 35 in Canada, 9 (26 percent) of Canadian markets were considered affordable, 19 (54 percent) were considered moderately unaffordable, 1 (3 percent) was considered seriously unaffordable and six (17 percent) were considered severely unaffordable.

Here is a chart showing the 15 most affordable real estate markets in Canada in ascending order: 


The final column in the chart shows the change in affordability since late 2006, the year that the United States' real estate market began its plunge.  Notice that only one market (St. Catherines - Niagara) has become relatively more affordable with three markets moving from affordable to moderately unaffordable.

Here is a chart showing the 15 least affordable real estate markets in Canada in descending order:


Vancouver, as always, is the standout for lack of affordability with a median multiple of 10.6, one of the highest in the entire seven nation study.  A total of four markets in British Columbia are among the least affordable communities in the nation, followed by Toronto and Montreal which are both considered severely unaffordable.  Toronto, Montreal, Quebec City, Saskatoon and Vancouver show the greatest decreases in affordability among the 15 most unaffordable cities in Canada with Vancouver, once again, being the standout.

In summary, it is my suspicion that the current level of affordability in Canada's real estate market is unsustainable, particularly if the country follows the rest of the world into a recession.   With only 26 percent of the nation's 35 real estate markets falling into the affordable category and 17 percent falling into the severely unaffordable category, prices over the long-term are unsupportable.   People simply will not be able to sustain their current excessive levels of debt once interest rates start their climb back to historical norms.   It is only the Bank of Canada's ultra-low interest policy that has kept the "bubble" alive as long as it has been despite all of Mr. Carney's warnings about consumer over-indebtedness. 

30 comments:

  1. Your analysis is very simple but it's very good. Instead of taking the gross income I would have picked the net income ( or disposable income) to reflect the tax effect. As we know, taxes in Quebec are higher than in other provinces, therefore it underestimate the ratio for Montreal and probably increse a little bit Vancouver and Calgary.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This seems to be a very informative blog. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to read more articles written by you. Real Estate Investments helps take the guesswork out of real estate investing. Real estate investment properties are a dual task business. A new world of financial possibilities appears at your fingertips when you start to incorporate cash flow into your portfolio. Reliable and dependable returns are yielded from these structured investments of real estate market. Through all this you can plan your financial future as well.

    For more information related to american real estate market please visit american real estate investments

    ReplyDelete
  3. Very informative, thank you.
    I would agree with the net income note, which would signify disposable income role, directly relevant to RE buying power.
    What I would also like to see is indebtness per capita for each market, or perhaps also the ratio of equity and mortgages for specific areas.
    I feel that e.g. Toronto has higher mortgage to equity ratio because of immigration levels and potential for employment is higher, compared to Vancouver where immigrants bring wealth and income potential from employment is lower.
    It would be inteesting to see those numbers.

    ReplyDelete
  4. its may be nice blog!!!it will be very interesting to share with us....nice thoughts for your great work!!!
    we also have real estate investing information!!!
    visit:dave lindahl

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks for sharing this information about Canada's real estate market. This is a nice information and it is really interesting also. Keep it up.

    Kirstz @ investment philippines

    ReplyDelete
  6. Check this out > www.montrealrealestatesource.com

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great Post! It's very nice to read this info from someone that actually knows what they are talking about.
    Commercial Investment Properties

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks for this info. Still, maybe Canadian real estate will perform better in the next coming years. In fact, Canadian real estate performed well than other countries.

    ReplyDelete
  9. A good new's for everyone miami real estate recently propose their client's to give their good's in low price and with lot's of discount and gift's so please stay with us and pray for miami real estate for it's golden era of all time........

    ReplyDelete
  10. Really if we are planning to invest in real estate.then we assured that it is not a risk because today's scenarios is completely changed.If you purchase house, penthouse or apartment it will give more money after sometime so it is dual business process.

    House for sale London

    ReplyDelete
  11. Getting the information about miami real estate, FL homes for sale used to be a time consuming affair, but with online search tools, it's never been easier. Just a few clicks can get you the knowledge you need on several miami real estate properties in your area of interest. Just knowing you've found the right number of bedrooms or the right price isn't enough to make a large investment in a home however, which is why americandestinyrealty.com offers much more.

    ReplyDelete
  12. really a nice blog abt canadian real estate market i really appritiate it keep it up

    One Ocean Drive | Midtown Miami Real Estate

    ReplyDelete
  13. Canadian real estate have a nice market outlook and I believe it will stay the same in the coming future.

    ReplyDelete
  14. really a nice blog good one about real estate thnks for sharing

    Midtown Miami Condos | Miami Beach Condo

    ReplyDelete
  15. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I think the market is now cooling a bit but the economists and realtors stay positive: Positive Outlook for the Canadian Real Estate Market in 2013

    ReplyDelete
  17. Very Good & helpful Content ,encourage me a come again and again.Your Knowledge about Real Estate Market is amazing.
    Herein, I am to drive you direct to the space of beneficial as well as space to living by:-
    Link - Indiabulls Enigma Gurgaon

    ReplyDelete
  18. Very Good & helpful Content ,encourage me a come again and again.Your Knowledge about Real Estate Market is amazing.
    Herein, I am to drive you direct to the space of beneficial as well as space to living by:-
    Link - Indiabulls Centrum Park Gurgaon

    ReplyDelete
  19. very helpful content thanks for sharing it. its very benefitable.


    Miami Midtown Condos | Miami Midtown Apartments

    ReplyDelete
  20. nice work thanks for sharing such a wonderful information.. i am impressed very much.

    Miami Midtown Condos | Miami Midtown Apartments

    ReplyDelete
  21. To be honest, I don't work very hard (only part-time and only when I feel like it) but yet I am able to get a lot of profitable real estate deals and make in the top 1% of Canadian household incomes! Years ago, I discovered how to do it from other highly successful real estate investors.. By working smart, and not just work hard. And I have kept this a secret until now... So how exactly do I do it? I am about to reveal to you an industry secret that can easily by your shortcut to your success!
    Click here to learn more>> http://bit.ly/YIWA2p
    P.S. Find homes up to 50% below market now at this site:http://bit.ly/YIWA2p

    ReplyDelete
  22. I have enjoyed reading your articles. It is well written. It looks like you spend a large amount of time and effort in writing the blog. I am appreciating your effort. You can visit my website.
    real estate

    ReplyDelete
  23. Very cool idea, your "selling blog" is in fact a very cool and one of the most beautiful "real estate" websites :-)

    One remark though. Your "leave the website online" hint is acceptable, but probably the new owners don't want to have a full view on their house all the way on the Internet - if they care about robbery. I recently bought a house and I asked the previous owners to remove the house from the real estate websites. Thanks to share this blog with informative information about house sale with us.
    Thornhill Homes For Sale .

    ReplyDelete
  24. Really great post, Thank you for sharing This knowledge.Excellently written article, if only all bloggers offered the same level of content as you, the internet would be a much better place. Please keep it up!
    Milan Rubenstein

    ReplyDelete
  25. Thanks for the kind comments. I am happy that you find this article very useful. Please do drop by frequently as I'll publish more tips and other tactics to help you increase your sales. Hope to see you again here Old Naples Real Estate

    ReplyDelete
  26. Data accuracy remains key to success, and it boggles me why there is so much data inaccuracy on Zillow, Trulia and other real state websites, when they feed directly from the MLS?

    ReplyDelete
  27. It was an amazing experience to see this excellent blog
    Real state

    ReplyDelete
  28. I thought it was going to be some boring old post, but it really compensated for my time. I will post a link to this page on my blog. I am sure my visitors will find that very useful.

    professional home inspections & home inspections Orlando Kissimmee

    ReplyDelete
  29. most of which have yields currently in the 4 to 5% range. However, the 3.90% is at historical low. Eddie Yan

    ReplyDelete