Showing posts with label copyright. Show all posts
Showing posts with label copyright. Show all posts

Monday, June 6, 2011

Piracy and Counterfeiting - The U.S. Trade Representative is very unhappy!

The Office of the United States Trade Representative (USTR) released their annual "2011 Special 301 Report" recently.  While it sounds more like a medicinal cream that one would use on a particularly itchy rash, it is actually an annual review of the protection and enforcement of global intellectual property rights (IPR).  The USTR is resolved to ensure that American IPR are maintained throughout the world to protect the holders of American copyrights.  In part, the report addresses the challenges of copyright piracy over the Internet in evil countries including Canada, Spain, Italy and Russia.  Nations that are seen to be in violation of American copyrights are placed on either a Priority Watch List (the really evil countries) or a Watch List (the somewhat less evil countries).

The 2011 Special 301 report examined Intellectual Property Rights in 77 nations that trade with the United States and has concluded that the following 42 nations have been naughty:

Priority Watch List:  Algeria, Argentina, Canada, Chile, China, India, Israel, Indonesia, Pakistan, Russia, Thailand, Venezuela.

Watch List:  Belarus, Bolivia, Brazil, Brunei, Colombia, Costa Rica, Dominican Republic, Ecuador, Egypt, Finland, Greece, Guatemala, Italy, Jamaica, Kuwait, Lebanon, Malaysia, Mexico, Norway, Peru, Philippines, Romania, Spain, Tajikistan, Turkey, Turkmenistan, Ukraine, Uzbekistan, Vietnam.

Section 306 Monitoring:  Paraguay.

Here is a quote from the opening paragraph of the 2011 Special 301:

"An important part of the mission of the United States Trade Representative (USTR) is supporting and implementing the Administration’s commitment to aggressively protect American intellectual property overseas. Infringement of intellectual property rights (IPR) causes significant financial losses for rights holders and legitimate businesses around the world. It undermines key U.S. comparative advantages in innovation and creativity to the detriment of American businesses and workers. In its most pernicious forms, it endangers the public. Some counterfeit products, such as automobile parts and medicines, pose significant risks to consumer health and safety. In addition, trade in counterfeit and pirated products often fuels cross-border organized criminal networks and hinders the sustainable economic development of many countries.

Because fostering innovation and creativity is essential to our prosperity, competitiveness, and the support of countless jobs in the United States, USTR works to protect American inventiveness and creativity with all the tools of U.S. trade policy, including this Report."

Basically, the USTR is acting on behalf of United States businesses to ensure that infringement on their property rights doesn't impact their ability to make profits.  The USTR is also concerned about counterfeit drugs, automobile and airplane parts, toothpaste, shampoo, razors, batteries, food and beverages, sporting goods and other manufactured items that we use every day since these counterfeit products could endanger the public and could be contributing to cross-border organized crime.  Interestingly enough, the USTR is concerned that countries that suffer from rampant counterfeiting and piracy are losing tax revenue since the counterfeit trade incurs no taxes or duties.

One issue that the USTR takes particular umbrage with is piracy over the internet and that is what this posting will focus on.  Now that many nations have given up their dialup internet access for high speed broadband, the USTR notes that the internet is a marvellous vehicle for the dissemination of copyrighted materials.  Perhaps the USTR would be happier if we all were stuck with our old 28.8 Kbps connection speeds!  The USTR notes that internet piracy is a particular problem in Brazil, Canada, China, India, Italy, Russia, Spain and the Ukraine.  Pirated products include the obvious movies and music as well as "apps", ring tones, ebooks and games.  Piracy is now a mobile problem with the advent of smart phones and tablets.  Here's another quote from the report:

"To encourage strong action against piracy over the Internet, the United States will seek to work with the following trading partners to strengthen legal regimes and enhance enforcement: Argentina, Belarus, Brazil, Brunei, Canada, Colombia, India, Italy, Malaysia, Mexico, Philippines, Romania, Russia, Spain, Thailand, Turkey, Ukraine, Venezuela, and Vietnam."

I love the use of the words "work with".  It's always nice to know that "sovereignty" is such a nebulous concept when it comes to protection of profits.

Let's take a more detailed look at a couple of the nations on the Priority Watch List, Canada and China.

1.) Canada: I found it rather surprising to find Canada right up there with Russia, Venezuela, Pakistan and India when it comes to getting a finger wag from the USTR for bad behaviour.  Here's yet another quote from the section of the report discussing the ills of America's closest trading partner:

"Canada remains on the Priority Watch List. The United States continues to urge Canada to implement its previous commitments to improve its legal framework for IPR protection and enforcement. Unfortunately, Canadian efforts in 2010 to enact long-awaited copyright legislation were unsuccessful. The United States encourages Canada to make the enactment of copyright legislation that addresses the challenges of piracy over the Internet, including by fully implementing the WIPO Internet Treaties, a priority for its new government. The United States encourages Canada to provide for deterrent-level sentences to be imposed for IPR violations, as well as to strengthen enforcement efforts, including at the border."

According to the USTR, Canada should provide its border Customs agents with the authority to stop the transportation of pirated goods across its borders simply because of their position as Customs agents.

Canada has tried several times to introduce new copyright legislation that ends up dying when the Harper government either prorogues Parliament or holds an election.  The latest attempt, Bill C-32 which you can find at the interestingly named "Balanced Copyright" website, was introduced on June 2nd, 2010 by Minister of Industry Tony Clement.  This was Canada's attempt to "...introduce legislation that will modernize Canadian copyright law for the digital age while protecting and creating jobs, promoting innovation and attracting new investment to Canada."  Bill C-32 was intended to "...bring Canada in line with international standards and promote home-grown innovation and creativity..." by "...allow(ing) copyright owners to pursue those who enable copyright infringement, such as illegal peer-to-peer file sharing sites."  Fortunately for all of us, the legislation was intended to protect internet service providers (ISPs) from prosecution should their nasty subscribers use their services to download all those copyrighted movies and music.  I would imagine that Bell Canada and Shaw were most appreciative!  Unfortunately for the Harper government (and much to the chagrin of the USTR I'm certain), Bill C-32 died a horrible death, having reached the point of Second Reading and Referral to Committee on November 11th, 2010 before the May 2011 election ended the process.

2.) China: This is the nation that seems to garner the lion's share of the USTR's attention.  In late 2010, China announced their "Program for Special Campaign on Combating IPR Infringement and Manufacture and Sales of Counterfeiting and Shoddy Commodities" (you've got to love that name) also known as the "Special Campaign.  This is an attempt to combat illegal downloads of music and movies, sales of pirated CDs and DVDs, illegal software, auto parts and pharmaceuticals.  For the first time, China's central government is now obliged to purchase legitimate copies of software for their networks.  In the online world, the USTR estimates that 99 percent of all music downloads in China are illegal.  Recent actions under the Special Campaign have led to the shuttering of several websites and the arrests and convictions of several website operators.  Fines for those involved ranged from $30,000 to $228,000 and prison terms ranged from three to five years.  Two major China-based video websites have now struck agreements with major United States studios to offer licensed rather than pirated content.  One website, Baidu, one of the USTR's "Notorious Marketers", will be offering licensed music albeit only with Chinese copyright holders signing up at this point in time, leaving United States rights holders still in the cold.

Not to worry you bad, bad nations.  The USTR has added a new program whereby offending nations that appear on their list can co-operate with the United States to work off some of their bad karma.  Here is a quote from the Report:

"...USTR is announcing that it invites any trading partner appearing on the Special 301 Priority Watch List or Watch List to work with the United States to develop a mutually agreed action plan designed to lead to that trading partner’s removal from the relevant list.  Agreement on such a plan will not by itself change a trading partner’s status in the Special 301 Report. However, in the past, successful completion of action plans has led to the removal of trading partners such as Saudi Arabia, Taiwan, and many others from Special 301 lists. An action plan may take more than one year to complete.  Action plans differ from OCRs, which are conducted between Special 301 annual reports."

As an aside, let's take a really quick look at a recent news item from New Zealand.  It seems that the government of New Zealand has become quite zealous about illegal downloading on the Internet.  In April 2011, the government pushed through a bill, the Copyright (Infringing File Sharing) Amendment Bill, which targets Internet users that illegally download or upload copyrighted material.  Under the law, ISPs will send warning letters to infringing downloaders and uploaders at the behest of copyright holders.  Repeat offenders will be disconnected from the Internet for a period of 6 months and could be assessed a fine of up to $15,000.  Ironically enough, a tweet sent out by a National MP set off a firestorm in the local media when she tweeted that she was listening to a compilation of music given to her by a friend, a potential infraction of the Copyright legislation.  Apparently the legislation puts the onus on the accused to prove their innocence.  As well, if the complexity of the legislation and the concept of filesharing (as shown here)  are barely understood by those who impose these laws upon us, how can the sweaty masses be expected to understand what is legal and what is not when there appear to be so many grey areas?

The tactics used by the USTR brings to mind certain school teachers from my past that used the technique of public humiliation to get their students to behave in a prescribed manner.  The "name them and shame them" technique is nothing more than an attempt to force Canada, and other nations, to succumb to the interests of the American recording industry among others.  Counterfeit pharmaceuticals and airplane parts are one thing; copying movies and music should be regarded entirely differently.  While theft is theft, I’ve always found it more than a bit annoying that with rapid changes in technology, one could have owned the same movie in Betamax, VHS, DVD, mp4 and Bluray.  In the case of music, one could own the same album as a record, eight-track, cassette, CD or mp3.  In each case, the changes in technology have resulted in complete abandonment of the previous iteration rendering rather expensive audio and video equipment completely obsolete.  Perhaps, in some ways, the recording industry has been its own worst enemy.

Now that Canada has a majority Conservative government, it will be interesting to see if Mr. Harper relents to the pressures from south of the border and updates Canada's copyright laws or if he tells the American Trade Representative to take a very long leap off a very short dock.

Wednesday, June 2, 2010

Who is Dictating Canada's Copyright Laws? Part 2

In Tuesday's Globe and Mail, there was a brief item on proposed changes to Canada's Copyright Act that would be introduced by Industry Minister Tony Clement on Wednesday June 2nd. This is the second time this legislation has been introduced; the first attempt in 2008 met with strong opposition and died a merciful death when an election was called. The controversial changes proposed in these amendments would tell Canadians what they can and cannot do with digital copies of music, books, movies and episodes of television shows.

I first posted on this issue back in March. At that time, I noted that the Harper government was being pressured to change Canada's copyright laws by the United States, most particularly as a result of the Special 301 Report released in April 2009 by the United States Trade Representative. The Special 301 Report lists countries that the U.S. believes need to reform their intellectual property laws. Canada has been included on that list for the past 15 years, in fact, Canada was added to the Priority Watch List in 2009 (along with China, Russia and India among others). The recording industry in the United States has been lobbying government and threatening consumers with legal action for years in attempts to end the practice of uploading and downloading digital copies of recorded media; now they are trying to export their efforts into Canada.

Minister Clement's amendments propose changes that would make it explicitly illegal to crack the digital encryption protection on recorded material. For those of you that aren't aware, digital encryption is used to prevent consumers from copying DVDs (even though software is freely available on the internet that will allow consumers to break the encryption and allow copying). To make these changes more palatable, Mr. Clement will change the rules so that consumers can legally copy music that they have purchased, for example, if you purchase a CD, you can copy the music to your iPod, in other words, the amendments will allow "format shifting". Imagine that, Mr. Clement is going to allow me to copy music that I have paid for (generally way too much for considering the quality of the content) to a device that I have paid for. He's too kind. I hate to tell him but consumers, himself included as he revealed last week, have ignored the stupid law that prevented us from doing that since the advent of the first Walkman.

What the proposed amendments may also do is to prevent consumers from decrypting and copying DVDs that they have purchased in other regions (outside of North America's Region 1) so that the content can be played on North American players.

Ottawa will also allow Canadians to continue to legitimately record television shows with digital video recorders for later viewing as long as they don't build up a library of recorded content. A question. How are they going to know if a consumer has built up a so-called "library" of recorded television episodes? Are they going to search our homes? Are they going to create some sort of device that tracks our recording habits?

I'd suggest that Mr. Clement take a step back from his political masters south of the border and rethink these amendments. It is my opinion that as long as I'm not diffusing the content that I have paid for through a web-based diffusion service or attempting to make a profit by copying the media, I should be free to use the content as I choose within the four walls of my home. As well, since the media used by the recording are fragile and highly susceptible to damage, I should be allowed to make a backup copy of a disk as long as I am not intending to retail that copy.

I don't think that it's any business of the United States Trade Representative what I do with my CDs, DVDs and other media that I have purchased and I suspect most Canadians will agree.

Friday, April 23, 2010

Who's dictating Canada's Copyright Legislation?

According to a report in the National Post this weekend, the Harper government is going to make yet another attempt to table a copyright bill this fall and winter. This bill is an attempt to update current legislation to bring it into the digital age.

I fail to understand how it will be possible to prevent copying and distribution of music, digital books, television programming and movies. With the advent of PVRs, recording of movies and television programs and subsequent copying to DVDs would be impossible to prevent with current technology. Under legislation proposed in 2008, consumers would not have been allowed to keep recorded shows indefinitely. Interesting idea but how would it be enforceable?

Since 1997, Canadians have been paying a blank media levy on blank audio recording media including CDs (and tapes although they are almost never used) of $0.29 per unit and the money collected is distributed to artists. By September 2007, over $100 million had been distributed to eligible artists. I would imagine that the Canadian Recording Industry and Canadian Motion Picture Distributor's Association are unhappy with the levy since consumers are using far fewer CDs with the advent of mp3 and multiple format video files. The Canadian Recording Industry Association has also attempted to have a levy assessed on portable digital audio recorders (i.e. iPods) and has also attempted to limit the ability of consumers to make legal copies of media for their own use.

Every year in April, the United States Trade Representative releases its Special 301 Report which lists countries that the U.S. believes need to reform their intellectual property laws. Canada has been included on that list for the past 15 years, in fact, Canada was added to the Priority Watch List in 2009 (along with China, Russia and India among others).

Here's an excerpt from the Report:

"Canada will be added to the Priority Watch List in 2009. The United States appreciates the high level of cooperation between our two governments in many important bilateral and multilateral IPR initiatives. The United States also welcomed the Government of Canada’s reaffirmation earlier this year of its 2007 and 2008 commitments to improve IPR (Intellectual Property Rights) protection and enforcement. However, the Government of Canada has not delivered on these commitments by promptly and effectively implementing key copyright reforms. The United States continues to have serious concerns with Canada’s failure to accede to and implement the WIPO Internet Treaties, which Canada signed in 1997. We urge Canada to enact legislation in the near term to strengthen its copyright laws and implement these treaties. The United States also continues to urge Canada to improve its IPR enforcement system to enable authorities to take effective action against the trade in counterfeit and pirated products within Canada..."

There's nothing like having the United States put pressure on Canada telling us how to rewrite our legislation, is there?

All of this is being done because of so-called concern for the recording artists. According to the music-law.com website, most artists make only about $1 per album sold and only when that album is sold at full retail price. How many times do you buy an album at full retail? The normal royalty rate for musicians is 9 to 15% with 3 percentage points going to the producer and 3 to 5 percentage points going to cover recording and packaging costs. This leaves the artist with roughly 6% (at best). Yes, the artists lose when illegal copies of their albums are made but it appears that the bigger losers are the retailers, the producers and the distributors. How many of us feel sorry for them? They create nothing yet they reap huge financial rewards from the work of the artists. The federal and provincial governments also lose great amounts of sales tax revenue when sales of pre-recorded videos and music drop. It is interesting to note that the provincial and federal governments make more on the sale of a CD than the artist that recorded it.

It is undeniable that any changes to the copyright laws in Canada are being to some degree being done under pressure from the United States government. These changes will provide little additional benefit to the individual artist who creates the product. The greatest beneficiaries to changes will be both levels of government and the retailers, producers and distributors of music and video.

I suggest that the government's motives for changing Canada's copyright laws are at least somewhat suspect and I dont particularly believe that the government has the interests of musicians and other artists at heart. Our government has to be careful that they aren't pandering to the bidding of American recording industry organizations like the RIAA and multinational media companies. They also should not be acting merely to satisfy their American political counterparts.

References:

National Post Report on Copyright Bill Changes


Canadian Tariffs on Recordable Media


Summary of Music Contracts


United States Trade Representative Special 301 Report - Canada placed on Priority Watch List