Showing posts with label registry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label registry. Show all posts

Friday, April 23, 2010

Wayne, Whips and Guns

Last evening, it was with great sadness that I read of the passing of Wayne Easter's courageous stand against his Party and leader on abolition of the gun registry.

Now, apparently he's flip-flopped and decided to toe the Liberal Party line again. Mr. Ignatieff left his urban ivory tower long enough to engage the rural Liberal MPs who voted for the private member's bill that would have seen the end of the Liberal's pet gun registry. He informed the 8 MPs that he had decided that he wanted to make the registry more palatable for rural gun owners by reducing the penalties for being caught with an unregistered long-gun and cutting the fees for registration to zero.

Mr. Ingnatieff also announced that voting on the third reading of Bill C-391 would be a whipped vote, that is, all Liberals would have to stick it to their constituents and vote along Party lines. This becomes problematic for Wayne Easter since back in November 2009, he voted against his own Party to better reflect what his constituents have wanted all along, quite a marked change after being one of the most vocal supporters of the registry for 15 years, especially during his tenure as Solicitor General. I guess Mr. Ignatieff doesn't want to take a chance on having some of his rogue MPs vote against party lines for a third time in less than 6 months.

Here's what Mr. Easter had to say to the Globe:

“To Ignatieff’s credit … he came to rural caucus, talked to those of us who had concerns … and over the several months I think we found a solution that in fact works. It’s a reasonable compromise that I think shows leadership on Ignatieff’s part.”

Well, I guess we can see where this one is headed. I had hoped Wayne would stick to his guns (pardon the very weak pun) on this issue but I guess it was too good to be true. Apparently, it's back to business as usual on the Hill.


Reference:


Tuesday, April 20, 2010

Wayne Easter, his constituents and their guns

It will be interesting to see how MP Wayne Easter (Liberal - Malpeque) votes when the Conservative private member's bill that would abolish the gun registry comes back to the House for a final reading.

Here's Wayne's history with the gun registry. Remember that he was Canada's Solicitor General in 2002 - 2003 under the Chretien government. As Solicitor General, he was responsible for implementation of the registry. It is also important to note that his riding is primarily rural with most of the economy of the Malpeque riding centering around fishing and farming.

In 1993, when Bill C-68 was introduced, Wayne voted in favour of compelling all Canadians to register all of their firearms.

While Wayne was Solicitor General in 2002 - 2003, if you wrote him a letter regarding the wasteful expense (only $629 million at that time) that the Liberal government had incurred to set up the registry, he would send you back a colourful little brochure that strongly proclaimed the advantages and necessity of the registry. He was obviously pro-registry at that time.

In November 2009, Wayne voted for Bill C-391, Candice Hoeppner's private member's bill which would abolish the firearm registry and destroy its records, after its second reading in the House. It has now gone to a House committee for further study.

Here are two quotes from Wayne after the free vote where he finally voted against his own Party and leader:

"I favour a gun-control system, but I do not favour a gun-control system that makes criminals out of farmers and hunters."

"There is a very substantial difference between hunters and farmers who have guns for either hunting, or pest and prey that may be a problem in terms of their operation, than there is for other types of guns or long guns that may be even in cities."

Funny how Wayne hasn't seen things this way before. This time, he claimed that he was voting for what the constituents in his riding wanted. What changed? His constituents were always against the registry. The riding is still rural, the same as it was in 1993. The only thing that has changed is that Wayne has finally decided to vote for the way that the people of his riding have wanted all along. What, you say, voting on an issue based on what your constituents want rather than along Party lines? Unheard of in Canada's House of Commons!

It is also interesting (and coincidental?) to note that the Conservative Party of Canada targeted Wayne's home riding (and 7 other ridings) with radio ads encouraging people to contact Wayne and tell him that they want him to vote to abolish the long-gun registry. Wayne claims that the ads nearly forced him to vote against the bill because he doesn't like being threatened.

Here's the webpage from the Conservative Party website:


It will be interesting to see if Wayne Easter has the same convictions when Bill C-391 comes back to the House for a third reading. Will Michael Ignatieff's threat to make the vote whipped result in Wayne voting as his constituency wants a one-time event?

This just in: the Conservative Party of Canada has just released a new series of radio ads targeting selected ridings, Wayne Easter's among them. The CPC is even kind enough to supply me with his constituency office telephone number just in case I can't open and read a telephone book. I wonder if Canadian taxpayers paid for these radio ads just like we paid for "10 percenters"?

The new CPC radio ad webpage is here:



References:

Wayne Easter Votes to Scrap Long Gun Registry - November 2009


Conservative Private Member's Bill C-391 to Scrap the Gun Registry


History of Canada's Gun Registry


Monday, April 19, 2010

A Registry by Another Name

Today, Michael Ignatieff announced proposed amendments to Candice Hoeppner's (Conservative) private member's bill that would scrap the gun registry. The Liberal Party would make these changes to save the much maligned gun registry that was implemented under the Chretien government as a misguided means of gun control. Mr. Ignatieff is making this move to prevent a fractured vote similar to what happened in December 2009 when some of his Liberal MPs voted in favour of the Conservative private member's bill when he allowed a free vote.

His proposal would make it easier for owners of long guns to register their weapons by streamlining paperwork, removing renewal fees and, rather than making non-declaration a criminal offence, he suggests that it should be a ticketed penalty for first time offenders.

What Mr. Ignatieff fails to realize is that many Canadians do not want the firearms registry in any form, whether it is free or easier is of no consequence. When the original gun registry was passed by the Senate in 1995, it divided Canada along provincial lines with strong support for the registry in Southern Ontario and weak support in the Maritimes, Alberta and Saskatchewan. It also drew a line squarely between urban and rural Canadians.

The original (and unworkable) registry has already cost taxpayers a whopping $2 billion, obscenely over its original net cost estimate of $2 million after collection of fees. As well, an estimated 5 million gun owners in Canada did not register their weapons rendering the whole system a very expensive farce.

It would be interesting to know exactly what percentage of crimes involve the use of long guns versus crimes that are committed with handguns which are already restricted. It would also be interesting to know how many legal handguns are used to commit crimes versus those that have been illegally acquired. These are numbers that seem to be very difficult to access.

Michael Ignatieff needs to step down from his ivory tower, analyze how and why the Liberal's attempt to organize a gun registry didn't work in the first place, ascertain whether the majority of Canadians actually want a gun registry and rethink his plan before any more tax dollars are wasted.

References:

Ignatieff Announces Moves to Save Gun Registry


History of the Canadian Gun Registry